First time at this lake too (see Buffalo report). I was excited to see how nice the Brook trout are in this lake. I wasn't dissapointed. Hooked and landed a couple nice (15" and 16") Brookies. Nicest I've ever caught. Used Buggers to get these, olive, black. I vowed to return! The color on these was not as brilliant as some I've seen, still pretty though!
Good luck to All!